Timeless Plush: Classic & Cute

Sanrio Hello Kitty Face Plush Pillow – White & Purple with Pink Bow – 2010s

Sanrio Hello Kitty Face Plush Pillow – White & Purple with Pink Bow – 2010s

Regular price $24.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $24.00 USD
Unit price per
Sanrio My Melody Plush – Christmas Outfit – 10” – Excellent Condition

Sanrio My Melody Plush – Christmas Outfit – 10” – Excellent Condition

Regular price $16.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $16.00 USD
Unit price per
Sesame Street Trumpet-Playing Cookie Monster Plush – Sings “When the Saints Go Marching In” – 2004 – Works – With Tag

Sold out

Sesame Street Trumpet-Playing Cookie Monster Plush – Sings “When the Saints Go Marching In” – 2004 – Works – With Tag

Regular price $30.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $30.00 USD
Unit price per

Sold out
Smoochy Pals Corgi Dog Plush with Pizza Slice Cute Stuffed Animal Toy 12”

Smoochy Pals Corgi Dog Plush with Pizza Slice Cute Stuffed Animal Toy 12”

Regular price $29.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $29.00 USD
Unit price per
Southwest Airlines Plush Airplane Toy – 9” Daron Jet with Smile Face – Official Colors & Logo 2010s

Sold out

Southwest Airlines Plush Airplane Toy – 9” Daron Jet with Smile Face – Official Colors & Logo 2010s

Regular price $15.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $15.00 USD
Unit price per

Sold out
Squishmallow – Cailey the Crab – 7.5” Plush

Squishmallow – Cailey the Crab – 7.5” Plush

Regular price $12.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $12.00 USD
Unit price per
Squishmallows Allina Pink Squirrel Plush – 8" with Tags – 2023 Original Kellytoy

Squishmallows Allina Pink Squirrel Plush – 8" with Tags – 2023 Original Kellytoy

Regular price $14.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $14.00 USD
Unit price per
Squishmallows Fifi the Fox Plush Backpack – 10" Bioworld 2022 – Red & Cream Stuffed Animal Bag

Squishmallows Fifi the Fox Plush Backpack – 10" Bioworld 2022 – Red & Cream Stuffed Animal Bag

Regular price $21.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $21.00 USD
Unit price per
Squishmallows Original Plush Octopus Toy With Embroidered Hearts Green & White 7"

Squishmallows Original Plush Octopus Toy With Embroidered Hearts Green & White 7"

Regular price $15.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $15.00 USD
Unit price per
Squishmallows Valentina Bunny Easter Basket – Cream with Purple Interior – Plush Handle

Squishmallows Valentina Bunny Easter Basket – Cream with Purple Interior – Plush Handle

Regular price $23.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $23.00 USD
Unit price per
Star Wars Mandalorian Plush Toy – Comic Style Armor – 7" Mini – Disney Lucasfilm

Star Wars Mandalorian Plush Toy – Comic Style Armor – 7" Mini – Disney Lucasfilm

Regular price $12.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $12.00 USD
Unit price per
Star Wars Wicket Ewok Plush – Mattel Disney – With Tags – 2021

Star Wars Wicket Ewok Plush – Mattel Disney – With Tags – 2021

Regular price $22.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $22.00 USD
Unit price per
Starbucks Bearista Bear Plush 88th Edition 2009 - Winter Holiday, Plaid Scarf

Starbucks Bearista Bear Plush 88th Edition 2009 - Winter Holiday, Plaid Scarf

Regular price $30.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $30.00 USD
Unit price per
Super Mario Plush Backpack – 18” – Nintendo 2023 by Accessory Innovations

Super Mario Plush Backpack – 18” – Nintendo 2023 by Accessory Innovations

Regular price $17.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $17.00 USD
Unit price per
Tenderheart Bear Plush – Care Bears – 13” Stuffed Animal – Basic Fun 2020

Tenderheart Bear Plush – Care Bears – 13” Stuffed Animal – Basic Fun 2020

Regular price $16.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $16.00 USD
Unit price per
Tupperware Purple Plush Penguin with Scarf – Promo Collectible Toy

Tupperware Purple Plush Penguin with Scarf – Promo Collectible Toy

Regular price $17.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $17.00 USD
Unit price per

Let customers speak for us

from 84 reviews

Seller packed and shipped with loving care of each item. Items were as described. Absolutely recommend this seller. Very happy with purchase.

09/27/2025

Aurora's Treasure Chest

Great shopping experience from purchase to delivery

milam

09/25/2025

Great find! Arrived well packaged and I love it.

Ryan

09/24/2025

Excellent vendor. Item as advertised and shipped quickly.

Joseph

09/19/2025

Great experience! Thanks for the hat!

Pedro

09/18/2025

Beautiful crystal !!! I love it ! But I do hope it’s a bulb vase like displayed

Debbie conte

09/16/2025

thank you so much, they’re adorable!!

pumpkin pie

Wonderful! Arrived as expected. Packaged well

Tina

09/15/2025

I love the antique fishing flies!

Ana

09/09/2025

Very happy with this lovely Haviland Limoges plate! Shipped very quickly and packaged extremely well. Arrived in condition as promised. Would buy from this seller again. Thank you!

Linda

09/05/2025

The experience was a great one

Abby

08/27/2025

I like the tie for my craft

susan

08/26/2025

It’s just what I was looking for. So soft and feminine. Love it. Dress up or casual. Highly recommended this shop. Will shop with them again.

Cydmichele

08/25/2025

Cute bird! I love it! Very Fast shipping, very well packaged, great experience, Thank you very much for it!
Esther

Del Castillo

08/19/2025

The creche is just gorgeous!!!! Exactly as pictured and described, and I LOVE it!!! I can't wait to proudly display it at Christmas time. What a great Etsy shop!

fergusena

08/18/2025

Item added to your cart

Collection: Timeless Plush: Classic & Cute

Sanrio Hello Kitty Face Plush Pillow – White & Purple with Pink Bow – 2010s

Sanrio Hello Kitty Face Plush Pillow – White & Purple with Pink Bow – 2010s

Sanrio My Melody Plush – Christmas Outfit – 10” – Excellent Condition

Sanrio My Melody Plush – Christmas Outfit – 10” – Excellent Condition

Sesame Street Trumpet-Playing Cookie Monster Plush – Sings “When the Saints Go Marching In” – 2004 – Works – With Tag

Sesame Street Trumpet-Playing Cookie Monster Plush – Sings “When the Saints Go Marching In” – 2004 – Works – With Tag

Smoochy Pals Corgi Dog Plush with Pizza Slice Cute Stuffed Animal Toy 12”

Smoochy Pals Corgi Dog Plush with Pizza Slice Cute Stuffed Animal Toy 12”

Southwest Airlines Plush Airplane Toy – 9” Daron Jet with Smile Face – Official Colors & Logo 2010s

Southwest Airlines Plush Airplane Toy – 9” Daron Jet with Smile Face – Official Colors & Logo 2010s

Squishmallow – Cailey the Crab – 7.5” Plush

Squishmallow – Cailey the Crab – 7.5” Plush

Squishmallows Allina Pink Squirrel Plush – 8" with Tags – 2023 Original Kellytoy

Squishmallows Allina Pink Squirrel Plush – 8" with Tags – 2023 Original Kellytoy

Squishmallows Fifi the Fox Plush Backpack – 10" Bioworld 2022 – Red & Cream Stuffed Animal Bag

Squishmallows Fifi the Fox Plush Backpack – 10" Bioworld 2022 – Red & Cream Stuffed Animal Bag

Squishmallows Original Plush Octopus Toy With Embroidered Hearts Green & White 7"

Squishmallows Original Plush Octopus Toy With Embroidered Hearts Green & White 7"

Squishmallows Valentina Bunny Easter Basket – Cream with Purple Interior – Plush Handle

Squishmallows Valentina Bunny Easter Basket – Cream with Purple Interior – Plush Handle

Star Wars Mandalorian Plush Toy – Comic Style Armor – 7" Mini – Disney Lucasfilm

Star Wars Mandalorian Plush Toy – Comic Style Armor – 7" Mini – Disney Lucasfilm

Star Wars Wicket Ewok Plush – Mattel Disney – With Tags – 2021

Star Wars Wicket Ewok Plush – Mattel Disney – With Tags – 2021

Starbucks Bearista Bear Plush 88th Edition 2009 - Winter Holiday, Plaid Scarf

Starbucks Bearista Bear Plush 88th Edition 2009 - Winter Holiday, Plaid Scarf

Super Mario Plush Backpack – 18” – Nintendo 2023 by Accessory Innovations

Super Mario Plush Backpack – 18” – Nintendo 2023 by Accessory Innovations

Tenderheart Bear Plush – Care Bears – 13” Stuffed Animal – Basic Fun 2020

Tenderheart Bear Plush – Care Bears – 13” Stuffed Animal – Basic Fun 2020

Tupperware Purple Plush Penguin with Scarf – Promo Collectible Toy

Tupperware Purple Plush Penguin with Scarf – Promo Collectible Toy

Let customers speak for us